Bruce Kennedy ~ WeedWorthy ~

Scalia’s passing could bring a halt to the Supreme Court’s consideration of any major cannabis-related rulings, at least for now.

The death of Justice Antonin Scalia has sparked a new political controversy in an already super-charged election year, regarding who will fill his place on the U.S. Supreme Court and in what timeframe. Scalia’s death has also raises new questions about the federal government and its current prohibitions on marijuana.

Scalia is remembered as one of the more conservative justices in the Supreme Court’s modern history; but on occasion he was a supporter of a criminal defendant’s rights. That support includes at least one marijuana-related ruling before the high court: the 2001 case of Kyllo v. United States, where federal agents used thermal-imaging equipment to scan an Oregon residence for excessive heat from suspected indoor cannabis grows.

The 5-4 opinion in favor of Kyllo, the plaintiff, was delivered by Scalia; who called such government surveillance a “search” and “presumptively unreasonable without a warrant.”

Justice Scalia’s death has left the Supreme Court in a sort of legal limbo.

"The entire tenor of this term has now changed," Stephen Vladeck, a law professor at American University Washington College of Law, told CNN. "The court can try to go ahead, but on cases where they are split 4-4, their only options are to leave the lower court decision intact or to hold the case over until Justice Scalia's replacement is confirmed."

It has also created concerns regarding a major marijuana-related case currently being considered by the court: a lawsuit by Oklahoma and Nebraska against legalized cannabis in their neighbor, Colorado.

According to that lawsuit the state of Colorado, by legalizing marijuana for adults, has “created a dangerous gap in the federal drug control measures enacted by the United States Congress. Marijuana flows from this gap into neighboring states, undermining [their] own marijuana bans, draining their treasuries, and placing stress on their criminal justice systems.”

Given Justice Scalia’s passing, “there are definitely questions now about what happens next,” says Sam Kamin, Vicente Sederberg Professor of Marijuana Law and Policy at the University of Denver’s Strum College of Law.

The Supreme Court considered the Oklahoma/Nebraska case at their January and February conferences. However, “all of that is made more complicated by the fact that they only have eight justices now,” he tells WeedWorthy, “So I don’t know what they’re going to choose to do with it.”

Kamin also expects the Court to stay away from other marijuana legalization “test cases” this year. “I don’t think anything will get there in time,” he says, “but particularly now I think they’re not going to take a bunch of new cases; I think they’re just going to wait.”

Recent News Articles

Friday April 26

Lawmakers Want Legal Protections For Universities That Research Marijuana - Cannabis News

in Law & Crime

by Bruce Kennedy - Editor in Chief

A bipartisan group of lawmakers on Capitol Hill is asking House leadership to protect universities…

1787 hits

Friday April 26

Hemp cultivation wins approval in Connecticut Senate - Cannabis News

in Cannabis News

by Bruce Kennedy - Editor in Chief

Connecticut farmers are one step closer to joining the burgeoning hemp industry after the Senate…

2492 hits

Friday April 26

Jobs in pot are at an all-time high, but the boom is causing rifts in…

in Finance

by Bruce Kennedy - Editor in Chief

Jobs in pot might be at an all-time high, according to a new report.

2160 hits

Friday April 26

How Marijuana Works To Help Those With Multiple Sclerosis - Cannabis News

in Medical News

by Bruce Kennedy - Editor in Chief

In double-blind, placebo controlled trials, MS patients who use cannabis oil, synthetic THC, or an…

2240 hits

Monday April 29

Maine’s marijuana dilemma: ‘Cannabiz’ poised to grow, but in a holding pattern - Cannabis News

in Finance

by Bruce Kennedy - Editor in Chief

Maine has no legal market for recreational cannabis, more than two years after it became…

900 hits